Guides / Buyer's guide
Buyer's guideThe business case for COI tracking software: how to make it to your CFO
Finance won't approve software because a certificate was late. They'll approve it when you show the hours you spend, the exposure you carry, and what each option costs against both.
Most COI tracking purchases start with a scare: a trade on site with a lapsed policy, or a claim where the additional insured endorsement wasn't what the certificate implied. A scare gets attention. It doesn't get a budget line. For that, finance wants numbers they can check.
This guide shows how to build them. For the options themselves, see the full comparison of COI tracking software for construction.
Part 1: Count the hours
Pick one recent quarter and count:
- Certificates read. Subcontractors times active projects times renewals and revisions.
- Minutes per certificate, including the endorsements. Time five of them honestly.
- Who reads them, and what their hour costs.
bcs, which sells COI tracking software, publishes one version of this math: 20 hours a week, 52 weeks, at $35 an hour, about $36,400 a year. It's a vendor's illustration, not a benchmark. Our COI Journal report takes the estimate apart and shows how to build your own.
Part 2: Count the chases
For the same quarter, count how many certificates came back wrong the first time and how many round trips each took with the broker. Each one is time on both sides, and time a trade may be working without the coverage you required.
Part 3: Show the exposure, without inventing it
Don't put a made-up claim figure in front of a CFO. Instead:
- Pick one live project and list every trade whose certificate or endorsements didn't meet the requirement on the day they started.
- Note what was missing: completed operations, umbrella limit, waiver of subrogation, primary and noncontributory.
- Ask your broker what that gap would mean on a claim.
That's a real number of real gaps. It's more persuasive than a statistic. If you want a starting point, our free COI risk check reviews one project's requirements against a contractor COI or two.
Part 4: Price the options
| Option | What it costs | What it leaves with you |
|---|---|---|
| Spreadsheet | Staff hours only | All reading, chasing and recording |
| Software your team runs | Subscription plus review hours | The decisions and the record |
| Managed service | Service fee | The decisions, and oversight of the service |
Published starting prices help anchor the range: bcs self-service at $11.40 per vendor per year, Billy from $500 a year, PINS Advantage from about $300 a month with most annual contracts at $7,500 or less. Others quote. See managed COI tracking services for the service side.
Part 5: Say who carries the risk
Finance cares who is accountable. Say plainly who approves a trade with a gap today, how that's recorded, and how it changes with each option.
A one-page template
- Today: X certificates a year, Y hours, Z gaps found after start.
- Exposure: on Project A, N trades started short of the requirement.
- Options: three rows, with cost and what stays with us.
- Recommendation: the option, the price, and the first project to run it on.
- Check-in: re-count hours and gaps after one quarter.
About this guide
This guide was written by the Forsured team. Forsured makes COI tracking software. Prices quoted are from each vendor's own pages as of the dates under Sources and change often.
Get new posts by email.
New posts on contractor COIs and project requirements, plus the coverage gaps we're seeing on real projects. Short and plain.
You're on the list. Thanks for reading.
No spam. Unsubscribe from any email.
About Forsured
Forsured is construction insurance compliance software for general contractors and the brokers who insure their trade contractors. You set each project's insurance requirements once. Forsured reads every contractor COI and endorsement against them, flags each gap with the reason, and keeps checking through renewals until the job is done.
- Project requirements with exceptions, not one template for every job
- Endorsement review (additional insured, waiver of subrogation, primary and noncontributory), not just the certificate
- A shared workspace where the contractor's broker sees exactly what's missing
- A person on your team approves every result, with a full review history
“What stood out to us is that Forsured doesn't just organize the paperwork. It helps us understand what meets the project requirements, what needs attention, and what needs to happen next. That clarity across the GC, subcontractor, and broker is where we see the real value.”
Send us one project's requirements and a contractor COI or two. We'll show you every gap we find, free.
Common questions
What is the ROI of COI tracking software?
It comes from two places: hours your team stops spending on reading certificates and chasing brokers, and gaps caught before a trade is on site. Count your own hours and gaps for one quarter, then compare them with each option's price.
How much does manual COI tracking cost?
One published estimate, from bcs, a COI tracking vendor, puts it at $36,400 a year: 20 hours a week, 52 weeks, at $35 an hour. Your number depends on how many certificates you read, how long each takes, and who does it.
Sources
- The $36,000 Problem: What Manual COI Tracking Is Really Costing You, bcs, May 14, 2026
- Pricing and plans, bcs, checked Nov 13, 2026
- Pricing, PINS Advantage, checked Nov 13, 2026
- FAQ: requirements, renewals and pricing, Billy, checked Nov 11, 2026
We link to the original reporting and research behind every post. This post is general information, not legal or insurance advice: Forsured is a software company, not a law firm or a licensed insurance agency, so confirm anything you'll rely on with your broker or attorney. Spotted something we got wrong? Write to hello@forsured.ai and we'll fix it.